RFC: Create a global login system for php.net

Project Governance
Author
Currently there are different login systems all over php.net:

1.1 Global login system

Overall Results

Yes
No
Yes
4 Votes (22%)
No
14 Votes (78%)

Voting Timeline

Dates based on UTC

Voting Breakdown

1.2 Type of global login system

Overall Results

Use oAuth provider GitHub
Use own system (hosted on php.net)
Use both
Use oAuth provider GitHub
1 Votes (6%)
Use own system (hosted on php.net)
14 Votes (88%)
Use both
1 Votes (6%)

Voting Timeline

Dates based on UTC

Voting Breakdown

Use oAuth provider GitHub

1 Votes (6%)

Use both

1 Votes (6%)

2.1 www.php.net use preferences

Overall Results

Yes, only allow setting settings with account
Yes, but still allow the old system with saving settings in cookies
No
Yes, only allow setting settings with account
0 Votes (0%)
Yes, but still allow the old system with saving settings in cookies
12 Votes (100%)
No
0 Votes (0%)

Voting Timeline

Dates based on UTC

Voting Breakdown

Yes, only allow setting settings with account

0 Votes (0%)

Yes, but still allow the old system with saving settings in cookies

12 Votes (100%)

No

0 Votes (0%)

2.2 www.php.net user contributed notes

Overall Results

Yes, only allow setting notes with account
Yes, but still allow the old system
No
Yes, only allow setting notes with account
2 Votes (17%)
Yes, but still allow the old system
1 Votes (8%)
No
9 Votes (75%)

Voting Timeline

Dates based on UTC

Voting Breakdown

Yes, only allow setting notes with account

2 Votes (17%)

Yes, but still allow the old system

1 Votes (8%)

3.1 bugs.php.net login

Overall Results

Yes
No
Yes
3 Votes (27%)
No
8 Votes (73%)

Voting Timeline

Dates based on UTC

Voting Breakdown

4.1 edit.php.net login

Overall Results

Yes
Yes, but still allow anonymous login
Keep old login system completely
Yes
1 Votes (9%)
Yes, but still allow anonymous login
2 Votes (18%)
Keep old login system completely
8 Votes (73%)

Voting Timeline

Dates based on UTC

Voting Breakdown

Yes

1 Votes (9%)

Yes, but still allow anonymous login

2 Votes (18%)

Keep old login system completely

8 Votes (73%)

5.1 pecl.php.net login and pear.php.net login

Overall Results

Yes
No
Yes
3 Votes (27%)
No
8 Votes (73%)

Voting Timeline

Dates based on UTC

Voting Breakdown

7.1 wiki.php.net

Overall Results

Yes, fully migrate
Yes, but still allow old login system
No
Yes, fully migrate
4 Votes (33%)
Yes, but still allow old login system
0 Votes (0%)
No
8 Votes (67%)

Voting Timeline

Dates based on UTC

Voting Breakdown

Yes, fully migrate

4 Votes (33%)

Yes, but still allow old login system

0 Votes (0%)